As proposed by Jean-Paul
Sartre, ownership extends beyond just tangible things. It means more than just owning
every day, common things like notes, photographs, books, papers, and pencils. Ownership
overflows its "tangible" boundaries to include intangible things as
well, like people, thoughts, and memories. According to Sartre, as we become
proficient in some skill, or we know someone or something thoroughly means that
we “own” it. My family is mine, just like I also own my thoughts and memories.
They are intangible, yet they are mine since as long as can remember; the
intangible ownership Sartre spoke about.
Although the tangible
things surrounding us; like our homes,
clothes, paintings, photographs, books, and knick-knacks are ours, they’re all easy to
show ownership to. They all mean just a simple trip to our favorite store and a
full wallet, or some free time with a paintbrush or looking through a camera,
reading words off a page. But, the other
things we own, that we put tags reading “mine,”
mean more than spending Christmas money to fill our closet, or coming home to a
nice warm bed, or putting colors on an
empty canvas. Our family, thoughts, and
memories become ours with more meaning than photographs and new shoes will ever
carry.
I’ve owned my parents since
I first laid my eyes on them as I became theirs too, when we created the bond
existent between every infant and their parents; usually the first people they
see. They are mine to call mom, and dad. They were mine to grow with, are mine
to laugh with, mine to cry with, and mine to live with. It was love at first
sight, “you’re mine” at first glance. As Sartre proposes, we have ownership of
intangible things when we come to know them. They were mine to take care of me,
mine to feed me, to clean up my messes, mine to hear my cries at night and to
spend sleepless nights rocking me to sleep, and in those moments I came to know
my parents on a deeper level, to create a deeper bond and ownership than I will
ever know or have with any human being. I gained ownership of their love and
affection, and of course attention. I will always be their “baby,” as they will
always be MY mom and dad. Although that love, attention, and affection of
theirs that I call “mine” begins to be less apparent as I grow up, it is still
there, and it will always be mine like it was since the beginning.
After the first sight as
newborn, when I claimed ownership of my parents, my family also became mine.
They were mine to carry me, they were mine to feed me, to buy me gifts, to make
me giggle as I grew from bouncing baby to the young woman I am now. Although my
family was and still can be obnoxious, crazy, loud, different, and quarrelsome,
they are still mine. I’ve known them for 17 years, and I have a deeper acquaintance
with them than I will ever have with anyone else, not including my parents, of
course. My brother, aunts, cousins, my
grandmothers, my grandfathers, my uncles; they are all mine. Their love,
affection, attention, and their yelling, my aunts’ goofing around, my eldest
aunt’s witch laughter that makes me laugh until I cry, my grandmother’s
fly-away mind, already showing signs of Alzheimer’s, my uncle’s rock and roll
soul, my cousins ‘diverse personalities; they’re all mine, as they were from
the beginning. I’ve claimed them, and held them dear to my heart, and these
traits they’ve conveyed to me became a part of me: MINE.
The one thing that’s
mine, and no one else’s, are my thoughts. Since as long as I can think, they’ve
been there. I’ve been acquainted with the voice in my head since as long as I could
think straight, and it has become mine. I have mastered the intangible thoughts
in my head. Thoughts of school, “oh my god I have so much homework,” thoughts
of friends, thoughts of family, and thoughts that don’t make sense at all. I’ve
become proficient in knowing my thoughts, knowing the inner voice inside my
head, gaining ownership to that what only I can hear.
My memories, the
intangible ones, not recorded in fluffy, glittered 13-year-old journals with
locks that I grew up believing could not be opened without the key, or
photographs; some stained with age, others from outdated disposable cameras,
and ancient VHS tapes of first birthdays and trips to Disney world, are all stored
in my mind. They are mine, and mine to remember. I’ve grown to known them thoroughly,
from reminiscing the past, although some are already beginning to fade despite
my young age. But, even if they are forgotten, they were always mine. Even if
they were of other people, strangers, strange places, I grew attached to them,
and I labeled them as mine and filed them into the manila folders in my head,
to be mine, and visited whenever I so pleased.
Tangible things tend to
fade after a while. They lose their pretty colors, they lose that “shiny new
toy” effect, we become disinterested in them after a while, and set them aside,
and they no longer are ours. Our
families, our thoughts, and memories, on the other hand, although sometimes possibly
pestering and disappointing, are harder to lose interest and ownership of. We
throw away old books or give them away to Goodwill, but I can’t just give my
grandma away because she’s forgetful, or my aunt away because she has the most
obnoxious laugh in the world. I can’t just dismiss a though from my head after I
get tired of hearing it, or forgetting a memory because it’s lost its emotion
and nostalgia. Our family is ours from beginning to end. The meaning a new
blouse just bought at the store is non-comparable to the meaning of being
someone’s child, someone’s grandchild, cousin, niece or nephew, someone’s brother
or sister. A family is not just a color or a pattern, a photograph or words on
a page. The meaning we put behind our family, our thoughts, and memories is
what proves our true ownership. My family means to me long conversations,
birthday parties spent together, arguments, and 149019hours of getting to know each
other, creating a bond that will last forever; making them mine. My thoughts
mean to me things I was afraid of saying out loud, things that invaded my mind,
things I could not get off my mind, and things that only I knew; mine. My
memories; they’re also mine. More than just the faded images of faces and
places, but records made that one day I will be able to tell my successors. These
intangible things that we cannot hold, cannot really see, and cannot fully explain
ownership of, are ours, just as the tangible things we own are ours too.
Hey Brisa, so I loved this very much. It was very heart felt. It seemslike a lot of us had the same ideas in mind when it came to using personal evidence instead of factual. It seems like that was thr route to take. I love the imput of family and memories. When it came to the family part, at some points it was a bit redundant but you manage to get back on a flow which is good. Keep up the good work.
ReplyDeleteHi, Brisa: I agree with Briana that this is beautifully poetic; you've got a lovely ear for rhythms! At several points, you have really lovely insights into ownership. Here's a nice one:
ReplyDelete"I’ve claimed them, and held them dear to my heart, and these traits they’ve conveyed to me became a part of me: MINE."
It might be interesting to explore the flipside of that--does possessing something, being the owner of something, mean that you, too, are possessed by it? I would especially think that's true in the family example.
My only suggestion would be to see if you can pinpoint your argument. What do you want us to take away from each of these types of ownership that you mention? Even with poetic prose, you can build in a thesis about ownership; this feels more like a (beautiful) exploratory piece than an argument--and so see if you can find a balance between the two.
Hello Brisa!,
ReplyDeleteIts a bit intimidating commenting after Mrs.Parham but I will have to say I agree with her and Brisa. The blog really helped me know who you are and how you felt. Your personality shines throughout it. I felt as if your argument was that all of our memories are ours perhaps but I would have to agree with Mrs.Parham and say that you should try to pinpoint.
It was really nice to read though made me think of my own happy memories so keep up that work!
Great blog :D